The CFR started with a set of associate editors that will be rotated out in the future. There will be a simple primarily rule by which new associate editors will be selected in the future: researchers who submit good papers to the CFR. The papers may not be accepted, but papers that were reasonably close count in the determination. The number of submissions is not important. A secondary consideration is good reviewing. A tertiary consideration is age. We want younger associate editors. These are the three rules. No politics.