We try to treat authors like we want to be treated ourselves. (Obviously, this cannot mean that we accept too many papers.)

General Interest

The CFR seeks top finance papers, just like the JF, JFE, RFS, and JFQA. It differs in that it prefers controversial, unusual, and critical papers. It can take chances. The types of paper that maximize the distance between the CFR and the other journals are

  • papers that point out that previous papers and/or literatures are wrong;
  • papers that are considered correct but obvious by half of the profession and obviously incorrect by the other half.
Due to its goals, the CFR is somewhat different. First, its focus is relatively more tilted towards empirical papers. Second, it is not difficult to write a straightforward paper that has a good chance to be accepted into the CFR. The CFR would welcome good and competent critiques of papers from this document.

Pre-Submission Editorial Interest Indication

If you email me (Ivo Welch, the editor) a 200-400 word abstract for a paper that you are thinking of submitting, I will try to give you same-week feedback about my generic level of interest in your paper. Make sure that your abstract explains your findings—a generic statement such as "our paper considers evidence" is not useful. My quick-read opinion is not subject to debate; it is not a final opinion about your paper; and it is definitely not a commitment of any form. However, my feedback can help you gauge whether you are likely to find me an eager editor, neutral, or reluctant editor.

Do not complain if you get a quick desk-reject on a regular submission (and no fee refund) if you have not previously taken advantage of this pre-screen option. You have no right to a review or feedback. If I do not think the paper is not suitable, then this is all that you are learning for your $250. Most of the time, the abstract option above would have told you this, too.


Manuscript Submissions

The main submission website is

Papers may or may not be submitted double-blind. These days, google will reveal author identity within about 5 seconds to any interested referee even when the author is not named on the paper.

The CFR does not follow ordinary no-repeat-submission jeopardy rules. It even welcomes papers that it has previously rejected. However, the CFR is also more likely to reject these papers again. The threshold increases. It better be much better!


Style and Copyright Guidelines

Do not bother much with style guidelines before your receive an R&R. Instead, make your paper as easy to read as possible.

The style guideline is still evolving. Do not expect it to be perfect.

The most unusual aspect of the CFR (compared to the JF or RFS) is that we want most exhibits (tables and figures) to have a "description" section followed by an "interpretation" sentence or two. What should an interested reader looking primarily (only) at this exhibit learn from and remember about it? Look at the recent issues of the journal.

LaTeX

Especially (but not only) if you use latex, please look at style.html. It contains non-LaTeX-specific English guidelines, too. If you use and follow the latex formatting guidelines, you will substantially reduce the likelihood that we will have to come back to you and ask you to change your paper. See, if you format the tables the way we would have to do this for you later, you will notice when it won't fit, too. Using our styles will save both you and us a lot of time.

Non-LaTeX

Please look at the first section of style.html. You can ignore the subsequent LaTeX-specific aspects.


Data Policy

The data policy of the journal requires replicability of studies that are published in the journal. Authors are encouraged to post data snippets and programs to facilitate replication, but are advised not to entertain inquiries from the general public. They are not expected to provide free support courtesy of their willingness to share. (Making data and/or programs available is prima-facie evidence of good faith.)

More details can be found here.

The data policy applies even if we forget to collect the data at the time of final acceptance. You must agree to provide it later upon request. Of course, it will take you three times as long then, so better help us early!

Authors who do not want to agree to these terms are hereby asked not to submit to the CFR.


Copyright

Authors must share copyright to their published article with the CFR. That is, unlike say Elsevier or Springer, both the authors and the CFR journal own non-exclusive copyrights to the published articles, and can either republish (or sell) the articles.

Authors who do not want to agree to these terms are hereby asked not to submit to the CFR.